Colonial Williamsburg Research Division Web Site

History Through Archaeology

A Catalog of Archaeological Sites from Williamsburg

This is an excerpt of William Pittman’s final report to the National Endowment for the Humanities on the cataloguing of four important eighteenth-century Williamsburg sites.


Matching Chinese porcelain saucers with interior painted overglaze red and black in fishing scene (catalog numbers 01598-04BA and 01599-04BA). From the Custis site.

Archaeological research and interpretation at the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation have been mainstays of the research program that has made possible of the restoration the eighteenth-century town of Williamsburg. The extensive archaeological artifact collection—retrieved in the course of nearly seventy years of excavation—is used daily by historians, architects, decorative arts curators, historical interpreters, and material culture specialists to portray accurately the landscapes and lifestyles of the colonial capital’s inhabitants. The collection, believed to be one of the largest of its kind in North America, is a treasure trove containing a wealth of information about urban domestic lifestyles, urban landscapes, pre-industrial trades and crafts, consumerism, and colonial trade.

Through the generosity of the National Endowment for the Humanities, in 1994 the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation’s Department of Archaeological Research began a two-year cataloging project titled History Through Archaeology: A Catalog of Archaeological Sites in Williamsburg Virginia. The project’s objective was to create a machine-readable archive for the most significant portions of the four most frequently accessed archaeological assemblages in Colonial Williamsburg’s archaeological collections. The resulting artifact inventories and object catalog make accessing these assemblages simple and efficient. Analysis and interpretation of this collection remains a focal point of Colonial Williamsburg’s historical research which is aimed at the recreation of the colonial town of Williamsburg.

Prior to this grant-funded cataloging endeavor, the archaeological collections were not systematically cataloged, and only a small portion of the objects were documented in formal written records. To remedy this lack of documentation, Colonial Williamsburg created linked databases using a museum management software called Re:discovery. The linked modules in this program make it possible to catalog artifacts on two levels—as individual fragments linked to their archaeological contexts and as unique objects with full descriptions, video images, and cross-mend information. The fragment inventories are useful for certain types of archaeological analyses, such as distribution mapping (analyses that deal with the density of artifact types on a site that suggest functional behavior patterns). The more complete object records are invaluable in comparative studies of public and private households and trade sites. Context records and other documentary materials are cataloged into Re:discovery to complete the user-friendly archive.

Cataloguing Staff

Funding for this project began in July 1994 with a search for the best-qualified cataloging staff. Two individuals with years of experience were hired. Ms. Kelly Ladd, senior cataloger for the James River Institute for Archaeology, and Ms. Leslie McFaden, project archaeologist and laboratory technician for many years in the Department of Archaeological Research, were eminently qualified to undertake the important job of creating the archive. Each received a full month of refresher training in eighteenth-century material culture that was designed to coordinate their approach to artifacts so that data entry would be accomplished more efficiently and consistently. The training included a thorough familiarization with the new software program so that actual cataloging work could begin at full speed. Department of Archaeological Research staff members Meredith Poole, Kathleen Meatyard, Gregory Brown, and William Pittman completed the cataloging team. Ms. Poole was responsible for evaluating the excavation field records so that the catalogers could concentrate on those features with the highest degree of archaeological integrity. In this way, we were able to associate the considerable amount of artifacts with the specific households known to have inhabited the four sites. Ms, Meatyard completed the exhaustive task of reviewing all of the documentary materials and cataloging them, while Mr. Brown assisted with computer applications, and Mr. Pittman provided overall guidance and administrative support.

Major Activities

James Geddy Site

The first assemblage to be cataloged was from the James Geddy property. This assemblage comprised household and metalworking debris (brass founding, gunsmithing, and silversmithing) left on the site by two generations of the Geddy family. The domestic and trade-related refuse was first inventoried on a fragment level after forty-six context records were entered into Re:discovery. A total of 9035 fragments of ceramics and table glassware were cataloged in 1552 records. In addition, approximately 10,500 fragments of items from other Geddy features, such as beverage bottle glass, nails, and faunal material, were inventoried. From the combined Geddy features, 1002 ceramic, glass, metal, and organic objects were fully cataloged in the object database between August 24, 1994 and January 31, 1995. Among the most significant objects were unusual English soft paste porcelain sauceboats, and a wide variety of English white salt-glazed stoneware dinner wares with matching drinking vessels. Ninety-two English beverage bottles and several rare French case bottles complement the ceramics. Organic materials from these mid-eighteenth-century features include six bovine horns that are thought to be related to the cutlery activities carried on by the Geddy family. Video images of 162 of the most important, complete, and most fragile objects were captured and stored in the database. These images can be called up on screen simultaneously with the written object records.


Metal artifacts from the James Geddy and Wetherburn’s Tavern sites. Left, small brass watch key, one of two found on the Geddy site (catalog number 03148-19BB). Center, copper alloy name plate, possibly a tag for a dog collar (catalog number 01207-19BB, also from the Geddy site). Right, small copper alloy padlock (catalog number 01612-09NA, from the Wetherburn’s Tavern site).

The material excavated from the Geddy property is remarkable because of the large quantity of metalworking waste products that were found in addition to the domestic refuse. Slag, flawed bronze and brass castings, discarded lead patterns, and many partially cut-up brass objects show that the Geddys recycled old brass alloys to make new objects.

Wetherburn’s Tavern

Work began on the Henry Wetherburn Tavern assemblage on February 2, 1995.The most important Wetherburn’s Tavern archaeological features included two wells, the builder’s trenches that surround the main structure, a very large trash pit, a unique series of pits containing whole beverage bottles filled with Morello cherries, and a large area of backyard sheet refuse and kitchen refuse all dating to the mid-eighteenth century. A total of 13,694 fragments in 2321 records were inventoried. From these fragments, 1346 ceramic, glass, metal, and organic objects were cataloged. Thirty-eight context records and 187 color video images of the most important objects were captured.

Some of the most notable objects cataloged from this public house assemblage include: leather shoes, woolen blanket fragments, and shrubbery trimmings, leaves, gourd seeds, and peach pits from the anaerobic environment of the well shafts. Of particular interest were the forty-five complete glass beverage bottles that preserved the remains of hundreds of Morello cherries. These bottles were buried in small pits around the building foundations and along fence lines in the backyard during Henry Wetherburn’s lifetime. Recipes of flavoring brandy with this type of cherry recommend burying the glass bottles to aid the maturation process. Apparently these bottles were buried by Wetherburn and forgotten after his death in 1760; they remained hidden in the archaeological record until 1968. Work on the Wetherburn’s Tavern material was completed in early September 1995.

Francis Nicholson and Thomas Jones Cellars

In early June 1995, concurrent with the final phases of work on the Wetherburn’s Tavern artifacts, our attention turned to excavated material from the Francis Nicholson House cellar, a wood-lined pit, and the contents of a well that was filled around 1720.

The Thomas Jones House cellar material was inventoried and cataloged beginning at the end of July and was completed by January 1995. These two house cellars and related features are associated with the Custis Site features. A total of 2524 inventory records representing 19,969 fragments of glass, ceramic, metal, and organic material was created. Two factors created the unusually large fragment count. As a merchant, Thomas Jones had ready access to a large quantity of goods and, when the Jones House collapsed as it burned, the objects inside were smashed into small fragments. One speculation is that some of the artifacts in the cellar fill were merchandise being stored in the house. Eight hundred twenty-seven objects were identified and full catalog records were created for them in the database. In addition, 277 context records and 163 video images were captured and stored in the object database. Some of the most important objects were elements of a late seventeenth-century Chinese porcelain tea service decorated in the late Ming dynasty style, large quantities of English beverage bottles, and previously-unknown coarse earthenware plate forms.

Custis Site


Wedgwood green handled sauce boat, from the Custis site (catalog number 01994-04BA).

Work on the Custis site material was complete by the end of August 1995. The non-cellar features on this site included a well containing a total of 7756 fragments documented by 842 inventory records. Seven hundred forty objects were identified and cataloged, with full-text descriptions, measurements, and cross-mend information. Seventy-five video images of the most fragile and unique objects were captured in the system and forty-eight context records completed the archive for this site. Some of the most notable objects from this site include a complete tinned-iron drinking cup, rare “Wedgwood Green-glazed” dinnerware, horticultural tools, and numerous beverage bottle seals hearing the name “JOHN CUSTIS” and the “1713.”

Anthony Hay House and Cabinetmaking Shop


Whieldon-type tea pot, from the Anthony Hay site (catalog number 2474-28DB).

Beginning in September 1995, we began cataloging the material from the Anthony Hay House and Cabinetmaking Shop. The Hay Site is an important site in Williamsburg because it combines elements of domestic occupation with furniture making and related trade activities. Also, in sheer quantities of artifacts, this site is one of the most prolific in Williamsburg. Some of the most notable objects are matching sets of delftware dinnerware, and a surprising amount of locally produced coarse earthenware and stoneware drinking vessels. The Hay site is bisected by a natural stream that contained a large quantity of well-preserved organic objects, including wooden furniture elements, wooden patterns, tools, woodworking scrap discarded from Hay’s shop, leather shoes, and even a fragment of an eighteenth-century oboe. A total of 2542 inventory records representing 7212 fragments have been entered from this site. From these fragments 1531 object records representing 20,090 fragments were created. Two hundred eighty-six context records and other documentation records are now accessible in the database for the Anthony Hay site.